top of page
Writer's pictureNaresh Misir

Non-Catastrophic Injury Settlements in Ontario: How to Maximize Your Compensation



If you've suffered a personal injury in Ontario, you may be entitled to a settlement, depending on the severity of your injury. For non-catastrophic injuries, understanding how settlements are calculated and what you can recover is crucial to ensuring you receive fair compensation.

In Ontario, non-catastrophic injury settlements cover compensation for medical expenses, rehabilitation, and more, but they have specific limits and criteria. This guide will explain how non-catastrophic injuries are defined, how settlements are calculated, and what steps you can take to maximize your compensation.


What Is a Non-Catastrophic Injury?

In Ontario, personal injuries resulting from car accidents and other incidents are classified into three main categories: minor injuries, non-catastrophic injuries, and catastrophic injuries. These classifications impact the compensation an individual can receive through settlement.

A non-catastrophic injury is an injury that does not fall into the minor injury category (e.g., sprains, bruises) and does not meet the criteria for catastrophic impairment. These injuries may involve more significant trauma, such as broken bones or serious soft tissue damage, but they do not result in life-altering impairments like those classified as catastrophic.

For non-catastrophic injuries, Ontario’s accident benefit system offers compensation to cover medical rehabilitation and other expenses, but there is a cap. As of 2024, the maximum settlement for non-catastrophic injuries is $65,000. This cap includes:

  • Medical and Rehabilitation Costs: Expenses related to treatment and recovery.

  • Attendant Care: Costs associated with hiring help for daily tasks.

  • Income Replacement: Compensation for wages lost due to the injury.

Understanding this cap is key for anyone pursuing a non-catastrophic injury settlement. It ensures that individuals are aware of the financial limits they can expect, which often leaves people seeking ways to maximize their compensation.


Non-Catastrophic vs. Catastrophic Injury Settlements in Ontario

While non-catastrophic injuries are serious, the compensation available is significantly lower than for catastrophic injuries. The distinction between non-catastrophic and catastrophic injuries is important because the type of injury impacts the potential settlement amount.

What is a Catastrophic Injury?

A catastrophic injury is defined by specific criteria set out by Ontario law. This includes injuries such as:

  • Severe brain trauma.

  • Paraplegia or quadriplegia.

  • Loss of limbs or severe amputations.

  • Permanent blindness or significant loss of vision.

  • A physical or mental impairment that results in a 55% or greater whole-person impairment.

Catastrophic injury settlements are much higher because these injuries have a profound and often permanent impact on the victim’s quality of life. For catastrophic injuries, the settlement can reach $1 million or more, covering long-term care, home modifications, and ongoing medical treatments.

How Do They Compare to Non-Catastrophic Settlements?

The most significant difference between non-catastrophic and catastrophic injuries is the amount of compensation available. For non-catastrophic injuries, the cap is $65,000, while catastrophic injuries can yield settlements of up to $1 million. Understanding which category your injury falls into is essential to know what financial compensation you can pursue.


How Are Non-Catastrophic Injury Settlements Calculated?

When determining the amount of a non-catastrophic injury settlement, various factors come into play. These factors affect how much of the $65,000 cap you may be entitled to. The process for calculating a non-catastrophic injury settlement typically involves looking at the following:

1. The Severity of the Injury

The more severe the injury, the higher the compensation. For example, a broken leg requiring surgery and rehabilitation will generally result in a larger settlement than a soft tissue injury with minimal ongoing medical needs.

2. Impact on Daily Life

How the injury affects your ability to work, care for yourself, and participate in activities is an important consideration. Injuries that prevent you from returning to work or enjoying life as you did before the accident often result in higher compensation.

3. Long-Term Effects

Non-catastrophic injuries can still have long-lasting effects. For example, chronic pain or mobility issues that persist after the injury will influence the settlement. These long-term consequences may lead to higher payouts for medical treatments, rehabilitation, and lost wages.

4. Pain and Suffering

Non-pecuniary damages, such as pain and suffering, are also a significant part of settlement calculations. Courts assess how the injury has affected your mental and emotional well-being, and compensation is awarded accordingly. While non-catastrophic injury settlements are capped, you can still seek compensation for your emotional distress and physical suffering.

Case Example:

A 35-year-old man suffered a broken arm and a mild concussion in a car accident. His injury kept him out of work for six weeks, during which time he also needed physiotherapy. His non-catastrophic injury settlement included:

  • $20,000 for medical and rehabilitation costs.

  • $15,000 for attendant care and services.

  • $25,000 for income replacement during recovery.

  • $5,000 for pain and suffering.

In total, his settlement amounted to $65,000, reaching the cap for non-catastrophic injuries.


Maximizing Compensation for Non-Catastrophic Injuries

If you’ve suffered a non-catastrophic injury, there are steps you can take to increase the likelihood of receiving the maximum settlement allowed by law.

1. Document Your Injuries Thoroughly

Keep records of every aspect of your injury, including medical visits, treatments, prescriptions, and any assistive devices you may require. Documentation of these details will help ensure that all expenses are accounted for in your settlement.

2. Continue Medical Treatment

Follow through with all recommended medical treatments, such as physical therapy or consultations with specialists. Ongoing medical care shows the severity and continued impact of your injury, which is crucial for increasing your compensation.

3. Keep a Pain and Suffering Journal

Because pain and suffering are subjective, documenting your emotional and physical pain can help bolster your claim. Keep a daily or weekly journal detailing your experiences, pain levels, and how your injury affects your everyday life.

4. Work with a Personal Injury Lawyer

Navigating non-catastrophic injury settlements in Ontario can be challenging without legal assistance. An experienced personal injury lawyer will help you build your case, negotiate with insurance companies, and ensure that you receive the maximum compensation available under the law.


Common Questions About Non-Catastrophic Injury Settlements in Ontario

What qualifies as a non-catastrophic injury?

A non-catastrophic injury is one that is more serious than a minor injury but does not meet the criteria for a catastrophic injury. Examples include broken bones, moderate concussions, or serious soft tissue damage.

How much can I get for a non-catastrophic injury in Ontario?

As of 2024, the maximum settlement for non-catastrophic injuries is $65,000. This cap covers medical expenses, attendant care, and income replacement.

Can a non-catastrophic injury become catastrophic?

Yes, in some cases, a non-catastrophic injury can worsen over time, leading to a reassessment as a catastrophic injury. This would significantly increase the settlement amount, potentially up to $1 million.

What steps can I take to get a fair settlement?

To maximize your settlement, document your injuries, follow all medical recommendations, and consult with a personal injury lawyer who specializes in non-catastrophic injury cases.


Conclusion

Non-catastrophic injury settlements are designed to provide financial relief for individuals who have suffered moderate to serious injuries that don’t meet the catastrophic criteria.


While these settlements are capped at $65,000 in Ontario, there are ways to maximize your compensation by properly documenting your injuries, continuing treatment, and working with a qualified personal injury lawyer.

If you or a loved one have suffered a non-catastrophic injury and are seeking fair compensation, reach out to an experienced personal injury lawyer in Toronto for a consultation today.


Take Action

Need Help with a Non-Catastrophic Injury Settlement in Ontario? Contact Misir & Company at 416.865.6274 or visit us at 880 St Clair Ave West, Toronto. We can help you secure the compensation you deserve. Book a free consultation today!
bottom of page